Rebecca and I went to see War of the Worlds last night- so I'll follow the blogging tradition and do a little review here.
The basic spoiler free part...
First- They showed the King Kong trailer. I must qualify my review of the trailer by stating that I absolutely despise giant monster movies--
Oh man, I am so there. Peter Jackson does it again. King Kong looks incredible.
Okay-- War of the Worlds.
Anybody who knows me well will know that I grew up with the Mercury Theater version of the story. I have a deep love for WOTW- it's like an old friend and I have enjoyed every version made thus far. The upshot of this is that I was a bit nervous going into the theater after having experienced the last few Speilberg disasters.
This is one intense movie. Yes, it kept us scared. I can't remember the last time I had such a primal reaction to a movie. It was almost enough for us to overlook the gaping hole in the logic of the movie. If you want to be scared, If you want to see the world totally and convincingly destroyed, if you want to see man turning on man in panic well- this movie delivers better than any disaster movie I've ever seen. It also honors all the interpretations that came before it very well (as well as strip-mining them for lines and imagery).
The spoilers...
Although this movie was a blast and kept you generally terrified there's a few bits that your logical mind simply rejects and one of those is the basic premise of the film. These aliens (the movie never claimed they were Martians) arrived on Earth at some point before humans had established civilization on the planet and buried their giant tripod machines so they could invade us later. Why go through the fuss? Why not take over the damn planet when you got here the first time- before there's a civilization to invade? It's that one gap in logic (and it's a pretty big one) that kept me from really getting into the film.
There are also a lot of nit-picking bits...
If everything electrical is rendered useless when the aliens arrive how is it someone is out there filming with a camcorder? And why draw attention to the gaffe by doing the matrix through-the-screen shot that has become so overdone?
The minivan they use in the film has the best gas mileage of any car I have ever seen. It must have been manufactured by the same company that developed the revolvers that can fire ten to twenty rounds that they used in old westerns. Actually, now that I think of it one of those guns makes an appearance in this film, too. Eight rounds (I counted).
Steven, if you're gonna kill the son don't rob the audience by bringing him back safe and sound at the end.
Another appearance by the shape shifter archetype from Minority Report (the eye doctor in that flick). This time played by Tim Robbins- who is completely under-used. He felt as wedged into this movie as he did in MR.
If these aliens are so advanced how is it a mirror fools them. And do you mean to tell me that they haven't discovered thermal imaging?
If the aliens are gonna spray blood all over their crops, why not just grind the people up rather that pull them out of the basket they're in- take them into the tripod- take them out of the tripod again- drop them to the ground- stick a needle in them- pump their blood back up into the tripod- and then spray?
All the nit-picking aside it was an enjoyable movie and I'll be adding it to my WOTW collection.